Tutorials/Using Other Window Managers with Plasma: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 12:09, 2 January 2023

Other languages:

Introduction

KWin is the default window manager (WM) in Plasma and has lot of features, but it only supports floating windows. Plasma lets you use another window manager, such as i3, bspwm or any other tilling window manager.

Warning

Other window managers are only available when using X.org. These changes cannot be made for Wayland sessions yet. With Wayland maturing and Wayland extensions being standardized, this feature could be implemented in Wayland^[1]

Most window managers require few, if any, changes to their configuration files.

Some considerations to be aware of when using another window manager:

Tiling window managers may have problems with components like panels. For some configurations, certain options will help alleviate issues

Most window managers do not have their own compositors, and therefore lack features like animations and transparency. If such effects are desired, a compositor is required - refer to Arch Wiki for options.
- Compositors can also help with screen tearing, however check first if you can resolve it with your video drivers, as this will be a more performant solution in most cases.

Set-up

To use a different window manager with Plasma, replace the systemd service for KWin with a new user unit for your preferred WM. A tutorial can be found in the ArchWiki.

Configuration

To make a non-standard WM work well with Plasma, some additional configuration may be required.

i3

Installation

Before starting the configuration, you should make sure i3 or i3-gaps are installed on your system. If they are not, use your package manager or Discover to install one of these two packages.

Configure i3

When you first start i3, its default global configuration (at /etc/i3/config) will start i3-config-wizard, which will provide a dialog for Mod key selection and generate the user local configuration at ~/.i3/config.

If you wish to maintain the same configuration across users (they can still override it with their own local config), remove the wizard invocation from the global configuration file and use it directly.

The following i3 window rules will help you with notifications and some other plasma windows:

for_window [title="Desktop — Plasma"] kill, floating enable, border none
for_window [class="plasmashell"] floating enable
for_window [class="Plasma"] floating enable, border none
for_window [title="plasma-desktop"] floating enable, border none
for_window [title="win7"] floating enable, border none
for_window [class="krunner"] floating enable, border none
for_window [class="Kmix"] floating enable, border none
for_window [class="Klipper"] floating enable, border none
for_window [class="Plasmoidviewer"] floating enable, border none
for_window [class="(?i)*nextcloud*"] floating disable
for_window [class="plasmashell" window_type="notification"] floating enable, border none, move right 700px, move down 450px
no_focus [class="plasmashell" window_type="notification"]

If you are using a non-English installation of Plasma, you need to find out what the exact window title of the Desktop is. One way is to do this is with wmctrl -l.

Instead of adding

for_window [title="Desktop — Plasma"] kill; floating enable; border none

add the name of the window to the i3 config. This example uses the German Plasma installation.

for_window [title="Arbeitsfläche — Plasma"] kill; floating enable; border none

Notification positioning can be tricky, since not all notifications have the same size depending on their content. You can also use coordinates positioning, knowing your screen resolution. For example, for a 1920x1080 screen and notifications in the top-right corner we can use:

for_window [class="plasmashell" window_type="notification"] floating enable, border none, move position 1450px 20px

If you want to unlock KWallet automatically on login, configure PAM and then add the following line to your i3 configuration file:

exec --no-startup-id /usr/lib/pam_kwallet_init

Configure Plasma

You may get into issues related with the "Activities" feature - activating it via keyboard shortcuts (some of which are also used by i3, like "Meta + Q") seems to make i3 unresponsive. Removing Activity related global shortcuts seems to resolve this.

To get the Plasma provided pager display desktops as i3bar, set Pager Settings > General > Text display to "Desktop name"

Bspwm

For the most part, bspwm requires little additional configuration.

A single Plasma panel, in most cases, is detected properly and bspwm will not place windows in its space. If the panel ends up presenting a problem, or when using multiple panels, the following may be added to .bspwmrc
```
bspc config top_padding size
```
where size is the size of the panel in pixels. Also valid are bottom_padding, left_padding, and right_padding. As many of these directives may be used as necessary for multiple panels.

Hints and Tips

DBus

Since Meta key handling is in part performed by KWin, you will have to handle these shortcuts manually when you switch to a different window manager.

You can open some Plasma components with DBus commands. You can use this to map corresponding keybindings to DBus commands. To find a specific DBus command, you can look at dbus-monitor or qdbusviewer while you invoke the component in a standard Plasma set-up.

More info on meta key handling:

Reddit post describing the Meta key - KWin relation

Blog post describing the DBus - Component relation

Some examples:

Open Application Launcher

qdbus org.kde.plasmashell /PlasmaShell org.kde.PlasmaShell.activateLauncherMenu

Open Krunner

qdbus org.kde.kglobalaccel /component/krunner org.kde.kglobalaccel.Component.invokeShortcut 'run command'

Open logout confirmation screen

qdbus org.kde.ksmserver /KSMServer org.kde.KSMServerInterface.logout -1 -1 -1

For i3, you can map a keybinding with the bindsym command. Use --no-startup-id to prevent the command from generating "i3" entries in the task manager.

Example:

bindsym $mod+Shift+e exec --no-startup-id <command>

If you want to map the modifier key itself, use the bindcode command - you have to specify the keycode generated by the key, which you can get via the xev utility.

Example for the Meta key:

bindcode 133 --release exec --no-startup-id <command>

For Bspwn, you need to use the bspc program. See Arch Linux wiki for more information.

More Information

Window managers (Wikipedia)
Window managers (Arch Linux wiki)
Desktop environment (Wikipedia)
Desktop environment (Arch Linux wiki)

References

↑ https://drewdevault.com/2018/04/28/KDE-Sprint-retrospective.html

[1] ttps://drewdevault.com/2018/04/28/KDE-Sprint-retrospective.html

[1]

@@ Line 23: / Line 23: @@
 <!--T:8-->
-* Most window managers do not have their own compositors, and therefore lack features like animations and transparency. If such effects are desired, a compositor such as '''compton''' is required
+* Most window managers do not have their own compositors, and therefore lack features like animations and transparency. If such effects are desired, a compositor is required - refer to [https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Xorg#Composite Arch Wiki] for options.</translate>
+<translate>
+<!--T:58-->
+** Compositors can also help with screen tearing, however check first if you can resolve it with your video drivers, as this will be a more performant solution in most cases.
-==Using Another Window Manager with Plasma == <!--T:9-->
+==Set-up == <!--T:9-->
-===Single User: Using System Settings=== <!--T:40-->
+<!--T:78-->
+To use a different window manager with Plasma, replace the systemd service for KWin with a new user unit for your preferred WM. A tutorial can be found in the [https://wiki.archlinux.org/title/KDE#Use_a_different_window_manager ArchWiki].
-<!--T:10-->
+==Configuration== <!--T:27-->
-This is the simplest method, but only affects the user for which it is added.
-<!--T:11-->
+<!--T:79-->
-[[Image:kde-i3-integration.png]]
+To make a non-standard WM work well with Plasma, some additional configuration may be required.
-<!--T:12-->
+===i3=== <!--T:80-->
-*Create a shell script (kde-i3.sh as an example), containing the following{{Input|1=<nowiki>
-#!/bin/sh
-export KDEWM=/usr/bin/i3
-</nowiki>}}
-Replace /usr/bin/i3 with the path to the window manager desired.
-<!--T:13-->
-* Start '''System Settings'''
-<!--T:14-->
-* Select '''Startup and Shutdown'''
-<!--T:15-->
-* Select '''Autostart'''
-<!--T:16-->
-* Click the '''Add script''' button below the list
-<!--T:17-->
-* Enter the location of the script created earlier, or use the folder icon to use a dialog to find it. Click '''OK''', the script will be added to the list
-<!--T:18-->
-* In the '''Run On''' column, select '''Before Session Startup''' from the drop down list
-<!--T:19-->
-* The chosen window manager will be used the next time you log in
-=== System Wide: Adding an XSession=== <!--T:20-->
-<!--T:21-->
-If superuser (root) access is available, a new session file for X.org can be created.
-<!--T:22-->
-This has several advantages: the alternate session is available to all users of the system, and changing back to '''KWin''' is as simple as logging out and back in.
-<!--T:42-->
-{{Note|The XSession file location varies between distributions, but is most of the time found in {{Path|/usr/share/xsessions}}. }}
-<!--T:23-->
-To add a session for an alternate window manager as superuser:
-<!--T:24-->
-* Copy the existing Plasma session file{{Input|1=<nowiki>cp plasma.desktop plasma-i3.desktop</nowiki>}}
-<!--T:25-->
-* Using a text editor, open the file and change the Exec line, and optionally the Description{{Input|1=<nowiki>[Desktop Entry]
-Type=XSession
-Exec=env KDEWM=/usr/bin/i3 /usr/bin/startplasma-x11
-DesktopNames=KDE
-Name=Plasma (i3)
-Comment=Plasma by KDE w/i3
-</nowiki>}}
-{{Warning|In versions prior to Plasma 5.17, use '''startkde''' in place of '''startplasma-x11''' in the Exec directive above.}}
-<!--T:26-->
-* The display manager must be restarted, most easily by rebooting
-<!--T:41-->
-{{Warning|Ensure the correct path and name of the window manager application are used when modifying the Exec directive. If KDE is unable to start the window manager, the session will fail and the user will be returned to the login screen.}}
-==I3 configuration== <!--T:27-->
-===Installation=== <!--T:28-->
+====Installation==== <!--T:28-->
 <!--T:29-->
-Before starting the configuration, you should make sure i3 or i3-gaps are installed on your system. If they are not, use your package manager or [[Special:myLanguage/Discover|Discover]] to install one of these two packages. You should also install a compositor such as "compton", since unlike KWin, i3 doesn't ship with an integrated compositor.
+Before starting the configuration, you should make sure i3 or i3-gaps are installed on your system. If they are not, use your package manager or [[Special:myLanguage/Discover|Discover]] to install one of these two packages.
-===Create a default i3 configuration=== <!--T:30-->
+====Configure i3==== <!--T:30-->
-<!--T:31-->
+<!--T:35-->
-{{Note|If you already have an i3 configuration file (usually at <code>.i3/config</code> or <code>.config/i3/config</code>), you can skip this step.}}
+When you first start i3, its default global configuration (at <code>/etc/i3/config</code>) will start i3-config-wizard, which will provide a dialog for Mod key selection and generate the user local configuration at <code>~/.i3/config</code>.
-<!--T:32-->
+<!--T:59-->
-[[Special:myLanguage/Tutorials/Open a console|Open a console]] and type <code>i3-config-wizard</code>. This command opens a small window that will help you create a configuration file.
+If you wish to maintain the same configuration across users (they can still override it with their own local config), remove the wizard invocation from the global configuration file and use it directly.
-<!--T:33-->
-[[File:i3-wizard.png|500px]]
-<!--T:35-->
+<!--T:60-->
-Some i3 window rules help you to have notifications and some other plasma windows as floating windows:
+The following i3 window rules will help you with notifications and some other plasma windows:
-{{Input|1=<nowiki>for_window [title="Desktop — Plasma"] kill; floating enable; border none
+{{Input|1=<nowiki>for_window [title="Desktop — Plasma"] kill, floating enable, border none
-for_window [class="plasmashell"] floating enable;
+for_window [class="plasmashell"] floating enable
-for_window [class="Plasma"] floating enable; border none
+for_window [class="Plasma"] floating enable, border none
-for_window [title="plasma-desktop"] floating enable; border none
+for_window [title="plasma-desktop"] floating enable, border none
-for_window [title="win7"] floating enable; border none
+for_window [title="win7"] floating enable, border none
-for_window [class="krunner"] floating enable; border none
+for_window [class="krunner"] floating enable, border none
-for_window [class="Kmix"] floating enable; border none
+for_window [class="Kmix"] floating enable, border none
-for_window [class="Klipper"] floating enable; border none
+for_window [class="Klipper"] floating enable, border none
-for_window [class="Plasmoidviewer"] floating enable; border none
+for_window [class="Plasmoidviewer"] floating enable, border none
 for_window [class="(?i)*nextcloud*"] floating disable
-for_window [class="plasmashell" window_type="notification"] floating enable, border none, move right 700px, move down 450px, no_focus
+for_window [class="plasmashell" window_type="notification"] floating enable, border none, move right 700px, move down 450px
+no_focus [class="plasmashell" window_type="notification"]
 </nowiki>}}
@@ Line 142: / Line 83: @@
 </nowiki>}}
-==Bspwm configuration== <!--T:36-->
+<!--T:74-->
+Notification positioning can be tricky, since not all notifications have the same size depending on their content. You can also use coordinates positioning, knowing your screen resolution. For example, for a 1920x1080 screen and notifications in the top-right corner we can use:{{Input|1=<nowiki>
+for_window [class="plasmashell" window_type="notification"] floating enable, border none, move position 1450px 20px
+</nowiki>}}
+<!--T:77-->
+If you want to unlock KWallet automatically on login, configure PAM and then add the following line to your i3 configuration file:
+{{Input|1=<nowiki>exec --no-startup-id /usr/lib/pam_kwallet_init
+</nowiki>}}
+====Configure Plasma==== <!--T:61-->
+<!--T:62-->
+You may get into issues related with the "Activities" feature - activating it via keyboard shortcuts (some of which are also used by i3, like "Meta + Q") seems to make i3 unresponsive. Removing Activity related global shortcuts seems to resolve this.
+<!--T:63-->
+To get the Plasma provided pager display desktops as i3bar, set '''Pager Settings''' > '''General''' > '''Text display''' to "Desktop name"
+===Bspwm=== <!--T:36-->
 <!--T:37-->
@@ Line 152: / Line 111: @@
 ==Hints and Tips== <!--T:43-->
-===DBus=== <!--T:44-->
+===DBus=== <!--T:64-->
 <!--T:45-->
-You can open some Plasma components with DBus commands. So you can map keybinding to these DBus commands. To find a specific DBus command, you can look at QDbusViewer.
+Since Meta key handling is in part performed by KWin, you will have to handle these shortcuts manually when you switch to a different window manager.
+<!--T:65-->
+You can open some Plasma components with DBus commands. You can use this to map corresponding keybindings to DBus commands. To find a specific DBus command, you can look at <code>dbus-monitor</code> or <code>qdbusviewer</code> while you invoke the component in a standard Plasma set-up.
+<!--T:66-->
+More info on meta key handling:
+<!--T:67-->
+* [https://www.reddit.com/r/kde/comments/6wn5lk/bind_meta_key_alone_to_do_something/ Reddit post describing the ''Meta key - KWin'' relation]
+<!--T:68-->
+* [https://zren.github.io/2019/03/04/activate-any-widget-with-meta-key Blog post describing the ''DBus - Component'' relation]
 <!--T:46-->
@@ Line 161: / Line 133: @@
 <!--T:47-->
+* Open Application Launcher {{Input|1=<nowiki>qdbus org.kde.plasmashell /PlasmaShell org.kde.PlasmaShell.activateLauncherMenu</nowiki>}}
+<!--T:69-->
 * Open Krunner {{Input|1=<nowiki>qdbus org.kde.kglobalaccel /component/krunner org.kde.kglobalaccel.Component.invokeShortcut 'run command'</nowiki>}}
+<!--T:70-->
 * Open logout confirmation screen {{Input|1=<nowiki>qdbus org.kde.ksmserver /KSMServer org.kde.KSMServerInterface.logout -1 -1 -1</nowiki>}}
 <!--T:48-->
-For i3, you can map a keybinding with the bindsym command. Example:
+For i3, you can map a keybinding with the '''bindsym''' command. Use <code>--no-startup-id</code> to prevent the command from generating "i3" entries in the task manager.
 <!--T:49-->
-{{Input|1=<nowiki>bindsym $mod+Shift+e exec <command></nowiki>}}
+Example:
+{{Input|1=<nowiki>bindsym $mod+Shift+e exec --no-startup-id <command></nowiki>}}
+<!--T:71-->
+If you want to map the modifier key itself, use the '''bindcode''' command - you have to specify the keycode generated by the key, which you can get via the <code>xev</code> utility.
+<!--T:72-->
+Example for the Meta key:
+{{Input|1=<nowiki>bindcode 133 --release exec --no-startup-id <command></nowiki>}}
 <!--T:50-->